Full Article
Evidence Summary
What is an Evidence Summary?
Key messages from scientific research that's ready to be acted on
Got It, Hide thisIn postmenopausal women, combined exercise interventions improve bone mineral density levels at 12 months compared with usual activity
Zhao R, Zhang M, Zhang Q The Effectiveness of Combined Exercise Interventions for Preventing Postmenopausal Bone Loss: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2017:47:241-51.
Review question
In postmenopausal women, does combining different types of exercise improve bone mineral density (BMD) levels compared with usual physical activity?
Background
As we get older, we lose bone mass or density and are at increased risk for bone fractures. After menopause, bone loss and fracture risk can increase for women. Exercise can increase BMD levels or slow down BMD decreases, although individual exercises seem to work best for specific parts of the body (e.g., spine or hip). Combining different types of exercise may improve BMD levels at more than one part of the body.
How the review was done
The researchers did a systematic review of studies available up to January 2016. They found 11 randomized controlled trials that included 1061 women with an average age of 55 years.
The key features of the studies were:
- women were postmenopausal, didn’t exercise regularly (< 2 hours/week), and didn’t have medical conditions or use drugs that could affect bone density;
- combined exercise interventions mostly included resistance training or body strengthening exercises and aerobic exercise (e.g., walking, jogging, dancing, stepping); some interventions included balance exercises and stretching;
- combined exercise interventions were supervised or partially supervised and mostly done in external centers; some interventions included some exercises that could be done at home;
- combined exercise interventions were mostly compared with usual activity; and
- exercise was mostly done for 3 to 4 days/week (range 2 to 6 days/week) for 12 months or more (range 8 to 30 months).
Women could use calcium and/or vitamin D supplements during the trials.
What the researchers found
Compared with control (mostly usual activity), combined exercise interventions improved BMD levels by a small amount at the lumbar spine, femoral neck, hip, and overall.
Conclusion
In postmenopausal women, combined exercise interventions improve bone mineral density levels by a small amount at 12 months compared with usual activity.
Effect of combined exercise interventions vs control* on bone mineral density (BMD) levels in postmenopausal women
| Outcomes | Number of trials (number of women) | Effect† of exercise interventions on BMD at 12 months‡ |
| Lumbar spine BMD | 9 trials (853 women) | Small improvement |
| Femoral neck BMD | 8 trials (809 women) | Small improvement |
| Total hip BMD | 6 trials (634 women) | Small improvement |
| Total body BMD | 4 trials (439 women) | Small improvement |
Glossary
Studies where people are assigned to one of the treatments purely by chance.
A comprehensive evaluation of the available research evidence on a particular topic.
Related Evidence Summaries
-
Nutritional strategies can improve body composition in underweight and overweight older adults
JBI Database of Systematic Reviews and Implementation Reports (2016)
-
Exercise alone, and in combination with different fall prevention strategies may lower the risk of falls leading to injuries in older adults 65 and over
JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association (2017)
-
Innovative hip and knee replacement devices do not improve function more than conventional devices and may increase need for revision surgery
BMJ (2014)
